I must say that this is one good book! The marathon is fantastic! I don't like that the name of characters I. e.the title of a chapter is read at the end of the previous chapter. Other than that its excellent!
At first I thought I wasn't going to like it because there is nothing like READING a book, but this was great. it gave me a better view/perspective on the story and I was able to understand it better as well as get other things done while I listened.
Love Roy's voice and the different voices of all the characters. Love the book. Great description in George R.R. Martin's writing. Roy brings the story to life.
Not really. I bought this book to occupy me on a long road trip, despite having listened to the first one already. The narrator is one of my least favorite. He can't do voices, so instead he just seems to stick his tongue between his teeth and spit all over the microphone. I can barely understand him. And if you watch the shows or have read the books in hardcopy, he'll ruin half your favorite characters by making them sound like pompous, fat old British politicians. There's no nuance to his reading and eventually he just drones into background sound and I miss half the story and can't remember what Ive been listening to.
Tyrion and Daenerys of course. I don't think I'm alone in that.
The narrator could try reading the story to himself first. He sounds like a parent trying to do a funny impression of someone his kids like, without knowing anything about the person. he makes Tyrion sound like a leprechaun, Daenerys a whiney little brat, and all the minor characters as if they're choking on their own tongues. He doesn't understand the emotion behind the text. He's just reading, instead of narrating. I love these stories, but I can't stand listening to anymore on audio. He's just ruining them.
Only if you have no other option. You'd be better off watching the show and reading the hardcopies.
It took me awhile to get into the first book, but now I'm totally hooked. I can't wait to see what happens with all the myriad characters and plot lines Martin has weaved so far.
My only (very minor) complaint is that the narration is a bit weird at times - Dotrice seems to weave between accents at some points, and totally misses the intended inflection of some sentences. I can hardly blame him, given the hours and hours of narration he had to perform, and it doesn't take away from the book. Just kind of annoying and preventable.
All the stories are far from happy and joyful - yet irresistible with superbly drafted cliff hangers.
Roy dotrice is incredible as a narrator, yet you labor with him through every minute. Sometimes very difficult to understand. Though, It will not draw away from the next part:)
Westeros in general is the most extensive and marvelous imagining of a country bathed in blood, war, deciet, and pain. George RR Martin is a genius, and will always be the author of this century.
Book three, because its the sequel.