I'm a nurse so I understand that families sometimes go thru a lot of stages when they have a child with a special need as I have worked with these famiies for many years, but this was very dissappointing after all the families involved had gone thru. I didn't care for the wrongful birth thing either, although I understand what the mother was trying to do in the suit. Just overall very controversial and dissappointing.
Usually I enjoy stories by Jodi Picoult; she is one of my favorite authors. But this story really irritated me! The story lines seemed very formulaic (take one part Not My Sister???s Keeper, change the illness, change the child who dies and volia you have Handel with Care). The recipe renditions were tedious at best and made me grateful for the forward button on my iPod. But the topping on the cake was the oh so predictable unpredictable tragic ending. I would pass on this one. Still love Jodi, just not this time!
The only reason I gave it one star is because I had to!!! I haven't written a review but this was such a waste of time I had to do this too. I can't tell you not to listen to it but it is worthless. I can't even imagine why someone would write a book this bad.
I have a friend with OI, and was interested that the book was about this disease. As usual, Ms. Picoult does a pretty good researching for her writing. Yes, there is a certain formula that had me guessing correctly, but I definitely got swept up in the lives of the people in the book, and really enjoyed reading it. I have read many of her books, and it is true that this one is the most similar to "My Sister's Keeper". I hope she keeps writing, because she is one of my favorite authors for audiobooks.
I love Jodi Picoult's work usually. The book is good and well researched but did not capture me completely like Perfect Match or My Sister's Keeper. The characters were not endearing to me and I thought the sub plot more interesting than the main one. I usually find that I can't put down a Jodi Picould, not this one though.
but the futher I got in the story the worse the whole book story became, and the ending was just a big let down. For a family to go through such terrible difficulties and then the breakup of lives and families and then the ending was such a let down. I felt like I traveled uphill for a long time and then when I got to the top of the hill there was really no rest, no landing. I would not recommend this to anyone with a disabled child, and you must have a medical background to understand most of what was being said.
Jodi Picoult always writes an excellent book and this one was good. But it went on for too long and at times the characters were too whiny. Not as good as some of her other novels
Jodi has the power to move your feelings from hating the mother to understanding why. the wau she draws the character is amazing. when you read it you can not stop
A most touching story and well written. Good book.
This author follows a formula of allowing the reader to see an issue from many sides, many points of view. As a biology teacher I like this because it gives my students perspective on how reproductive technologies add a whole new and heart wrentching dimension to being a parent. Much like "My sisters Keeper" in this respect.