I loved these 3 books. But I agree with Keri from Colo and another review. This book is not for impressionable children who are still developing their moral and religion beliefs. I am not a Christian btw, but still found some of the anti-established religion messages to be disturbing as this is listed as a children's book
Starr Crystal Animations
If you could set aside the fact that the supposed good guys are hunting GOD! Then this is a great book. I wouldn't even have guessed that the "authority" aptly named by the author, was GOD but because I read something another reader wrote had me looking for it.
Sometimes I think it is better for one to read a book before a comment??? Because in a way, that comment spoiled it for me. I loved the movie and wanted to books. I even have all 3 in hard cover and sealed as a collector's item. So I was glad to find audio books of the movie.
I had't, then to me, the "authority" would have been the head of their church order like the Pope or the one behind him.
Still it is a great listening and the descriptive writing leaves you seeing rather than listening to the story.
I really enjoyed the second book, but I felt guilty continuing onto the third because it is somewhat sacriligious. I did enjoy the characters though and the discriptions, if it wasn't for the reversed roles of good vs evil I would have continued onto the next.
This is a combined review of the trilogy “His Dark Material” by Philip Pullman.
I just finished these books. I very much wish I had not started. The first two books (“The Golden Compass” and “The Subtle Knife”) are not particularly well written. Not bad, but not great either. However, extensive character development and situations promise a climactic third book (“The Amber Spyglass”). Talk about broken promises! In the end neither the characters nor the situations are relevant to the story and the first two turn out to be a vacuous waste of time whose only purpose is to lure the reader in to reading the third book of this disjointed trilogy.
I am FAR from zealous about this stuff, and thought those who condemned JK Rowling’s Harry Potter books were overreacting at an irrational level, but these books are another matter indeed.
They are truly the most virulent, blasphemous, and obscene things I have had the misfortune to stumble upon. They are effectively the literary equivalent of offering candy to a child to lure them away for some sinister purpose. In fact, that is exactly what one of the characters does in the first book.
The depth of anger and hatred dished out by Mr. Pullman in his anti-God fervor stunned me. The world has not seen this level of extremism since the Nazi’s ravaged Europe. And I do mean anti-God, not anti-religion. His characters literally demonize and seek to destroy God.
Having wasted my time and polluted my brain with this trash, the only good that can come of it is to warn off everyone I can.
So… Be Warned! These books are Pullman’s platform for a many hours long rant of his malevolent hatred of God, and just about anything else to do with objective morals. Any person believing in a higher being, or even the absolutes of right and wrong, should consider this a MUST MISS!!
I've read all three of the books in this series. For a while it looks like it's going to be a great story, but then comes the lame part. I suggest you stop after the Golden Compass. You are not going to like the ending of this trilogy.
This trilogy is indeed diabolical. The temptation- a captivating nicely written story- but beware of the message- the world view that the book is advocating is that God is really an evil angle that is just pretending to be the Creator. The devil’s revolt was actually the work of good angles and God should be killed. There is absolutely no discussion or attempt to show a different viewpoint. The evils of the church are the evils of god. period! I listened to the very end hoping that there was going to be some discussion or debate, but no. In the end, this is a bigoted narrow-minded hateful worldview that is pretending to be humanistic. And of course there is no possible way to see things differently! If you think this is just a bit or harmless fun and should not be taken seriously, be careful. Messages like these may work on your subconscious reasoning. Analyze the message carefully! If you hate God this is the book for you.
The Golden Compass was an intriguing story, with a clever female protaganist and imaginative elements that fascinated me. This led me to listen to The Subtle Knife, which let me down. Pullman introduced Will, the male accomplice to Lyra, and made her look like an incompetent fool that generally followed Will around. I thought that the idea of flipping the monotheistic theology on it's head with the false God was an interesting idea and I was not afraid of reading the books for that reason, but Pullman's hate and negativity ended up ruining a great fantasy and left me in a slump. I can't get myself to read the third book, especially after reading reviews of it. My advice is to stop with the first book, the second book will bring you down. I love Harry Potter books - yes there are some non-Christian writings in it, but it's not hateful. Who wants to teach children hate? Pullman does!
This is the second book in the series and the author's beliefs begin to be known. Christian parents should not allow their children to read.
This is definitely not a children's series and those that make comparisons to Harry Potter are mistaken. Clearly this is the antithesis to C.S. Lewis' Narnia books. It is blatantly anti-God, anti-church (of any kind) and the sad part is that Mr. Pullman doesn't actually seem to comprehend the theology he so unabashedly despises. The story is engaging, but parents beware, this is a book with an agenda. It's a treatise dressed up like a story and with a rather mean spirit at its heart.