I like to read and always looking for a good book
Loved this book I think he did a great job on it I was interested the whole time it kept me guessing the end was something i didnt expect -
Was nice to hear the book version after having seen the Steve Martin movie version.
When you put the two together the story is more interesting with more depth and a deeper perspective that doesn't come across as well in the movie version.
Watch the film, read (or hear) the book for a full experience of what I think the author intends.
I was not impressed with this book. It reminded me to much of a high school essay written for english class. It was not what a expected from a comic great like steve martin.
I was able to get through this story, but it was pretty boring. I was hoping it would pick up at some point or have a good ending, but it just droned on.
It's been a month since I listened to this book and in that time what cream has risen has spoiled.
My lasting impression is I cared for none of the characters who's lives seem to revolve around sex and confussion. Is this life in Hollywood?
A tale of urban waste.
Listen if you wish, he does read it well.
I listened to this book in just two sittings. I loved Martin's story and his direct, deadpan delivery, which makes the bittersweet story funny and believable. I can't wait to watch the movie.
This is a dreary, depressing little book that's read in a dreay monotone voice by Steve Martin. The very least he could have done is read it with some expression. I'm half-way through it and feel compelled to finish it because I paid for it.
This was a dark, but well written novella. The main character, Mirabelle, leads a sad and lonely life that is punctuated with bad relationships. Martin really hones in on the dark motivations of the men in Mirabelle's life. Martin's celebrity, however, leaves you wondering if he is merely transcribing his own fantasies - leaving the listener a bit unsettled in their perception of this comedic actor.
"Shopgirl" does have its humorous moments, but it's not classic Martin. Rather, it's a darker brand of reality (if one considers LA to be reality). Martin's first full-length fiction book is as fully developed as the premise is original. Martin updates the age-old love triangle consisting, in his tale, of Mirabelle, a lonely young girl in need of true love; Ray Porter, a well-off older man exploring the ways of women; and Jeremy, a young convenient "knight," although he's hardly the shining-armor type.
The title character is Mirabelle, 28, who moved to California with dreams of a "real" life but instead finds herself dependent on a myriad of anti-depressants and working at Neiman Marcus to pay off college loans. Her void in social interaction parallels her life outside of work. A sex-crazed girl in the perfume department seemingly foils Mirabelle at one point, but isn't given enough description or time to develop.
Martin's prose is bland and overly descriptive. He does not provide enough depth or description in character development but goes well beyond when analyzing day-to-day life and characters' appearances and actions. This style occasionally impedes the flow of the story, but overall it enriches the text and forces the reader to pay more attention to one's unconscious observations throughout the daily routine. He accomplishes this with an omniscient narrator and thus lends a unique angle to the story. One technique, which Martin developed well but failed to use often enough, was his original dialogue. Like the great description of Ray's goal of getting into bed without a commitment, and Mirabelle's stereotypical interpretation of that as commitment and love.
The novel is too short to develop more than the superficial plot of love triangle. Martin is clearly new to the genre and his novella leaves something to be desired. But he has the mark of a talented observer, and I hope he will develop this in another work with a less convenient turn of events.