It is not a real comparison. I tried the audiobook for the french speaking and intonation. I am an adult trying to learn the accent for french and have found children's rhymes to be the best for imitating the right speech patterns. The tongue twisters are very helpful, as well.
I want to teach my children french in the future and think that the songs and rhymes and tongue twisters will be helpful and similar to the way children learn.
The speech and pronunciation cannot be learned from a book.
Not for a children's book
I liked the format for learning language.